The Incoherents: Victorian Paris Trolled the Art World

Discover how online shopping is reshaping the retail landscape and consumer behavior worldwide.

Categories

Branding, Web Design

Client

Arden & Co.

Project

Project Echo

Services

Branding
Art & Design Direction
Motion
Web design

Year

2025

Blog Image

On October 1, 1882, two thousand people crammed into a tiny Parisian apartment at 4 rue Antoine Dubois for what was supposed to be an "unusual evening." Among the crowd: Édouard Manet, Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Camille Pissarro, and Richard Wagner. They had come to see something unprecedented—an exhibition of art made by people who couldn't draw.
The host, Jules Lévy,
had a simple manifesto:
"Death to clichés, to us young people!"

What they witnessed would unknowingly shape the next century of art. But nobody was taking it seriously. That was the entire point.

Who Were These People?

Jules Lévy was a Parisian writer, publisher, and former member of the bohemian literary club Les Hydropathes. He wasn't trying to start an art revolution—he was trying to make people laugh during a dark time in French society.

The name "Les Arts Incohérents" was itself a joke, a play on "les arts décoratifs" (decorative arts), which was also the name of a prestigious Parisian art school. Lévy was essentially calling his movement "Incoherent Arts"—the opposite of everything the establishment stood for.

The Cast of Characters

The movement recruited artists with no formal training alongside established names like Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec. Writers, actors, journalists, comedians, cabaret performers—anyone who wanted to thumb their nose at the stuffy Salon system was welcome.

Key players included:
  • Paul Bilhaud: A playwright who created the first monochrome painting

  • Alphonse Allais: A humorist who expanded the concept into a full series

  • Émile Cohl: An early film animator who contributed surreal photographs

  • Arthur Sapeck (Eugène Bataille): Created the defaced Mona Lisa, 36 years before Duchamp

The Art That Shouldn't Exist
The First Monochrome: A Joke That Broke Art

At that first 1882 exhibition in Lévy's apartment, Paul Bilhaud displayed what would become one of the most important artworks in history—though nobody realized it at the time.

It was a completely black canvas, displayed more than thirty years before Kazimir Malevich's famous Black Square.

The joke was obvious: if Black people are fighting in the dark, you can't see anything. The entire canvas was just... black. That's it. That's the joke.

Except it wasn't just a joke.

This work is now considered by some critics to be the first monochrome in art history. In 2021, after being missing for 139 years, the painting was rediscovered and classified as a National Treasure by the French government.

The First Ready-Made (That Nobody Noticed)

In 2018, art expert Johann Naldi discovered among seventeen previously unknown Incoherent works a piece by Allais: "Des souteneurs encore dans la force de l'âge et le ventre dans l'herbe boivent de l'absinthe" (Pimps in Their Prime, Bellies in the Grass, Drinking Absinthe).

The artwork? A green cab curtain hanging on a wooden cylinder.

That's it. An actual cab curtain from a horse-drawn carriage, exhibited as art. This work has been classified as a National Treasure and is seen as evoking Duchamp's ready-made practice—which wouldn't happen for another three decades.

Blog Image
  • OFF KILTER /

stories to ignite curiosity and fuel the passion for a life well-lived. Join us as we redefine what it means to be truly Off Kilter.

OFF KILTER

Contact


Instagram


TikTok


X


stories to ignite curiosity and fuel the passion for a life well-lived. Join us as we redefine what it means to be truly Off Kilter.

OFF KILTER

Contact


Instagram


TikTok


X


stories to ignite curiosity and fuel the passion for a life well-lived. Join us as we redefine what it means to be truly Off Kilter.

OFF KILTER

Contact


Instagram


TikTok


X


Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.